Skip to content
Zarto Consulting

Assessments & Risk

Intellectual Property Assessment & Disputes

Know what your intellectual property is worth, and resolve disputes about it

Available to businesses across South Africa and Namibia.

What this service is

Intellectual property is often one of a business’s most valuable, and most overlooked, assets. Brands, patents, software, designs, recipes and know-how can be worth more than everything else on the balance sheet, yet few businesses know what theirs is worth.

We assess intellectual property independently, using the four recognised valuation approaches: cost-based, market-based, income-based and option-based. We choose the method, or combination of methods, that suits the asset and the purpose of the assessment, and we explain every assumption so the result can stand up to scrutiny from buyers, investors, partners or the other side of a dispute.

Where disagreements arise over who owns the IP, how it may be used, what royalties are due or what it is worth, we bring our dispute resolution experience. An objective valuation often takes the heat out of a dispute, and a structured, confidential process gets the parties to an agreement without lengthy litigation.

Who it’s for

  • Businesses buying, selling or investing where IP is a large part of the value
  • Owners who want to license their IP, or need to set a fair royalty
  • Founders, partners and shareholders bringing IP into, or taking it out of, a business
  • Parties in a disagreement over IP ownership, licence terms, royalties or value
  • Businesses that want to understand and protect the value they have built

What’s included

  • An initial conversation to identify the intellectual property and the purpose of the assessment
  • A review of the IP, how it is used, what it earns and the agreements around it
  • Valuation using the method or combination of methods best suited to the asset
  • A clear written assessment that explains the approach, assumptions and resulting value
  • Where there is a dispute, a structured, confidential process to help the parties agree

How we value intellectual property

We use the four recognised valuation approaches, choosing the one, or the combination, that suits the asset and the reason for the assessment, and we explain every assumption.

01

Cost-based

What would it cost to create it again?

We work out what it would cost to recreate or replace the intellectual property today: the research, development, design, testing and registration behind it, adjusted for age and obsolescence.

Best for: Newer IP, internal software and assets with no clear income yet

02

Market-based

What have similar assets sold or licensed for?

We compare the IP with sales and licence agreements for similar assets, adjusting for differences in market, exclusivity, territory, remaining life and risk.

Best for: Trademarks, licences and IP with an active market

03

Income-based

What will it earn for the business?

We estimate the future income the IP will generate and discount it to today, using methods such as relief-from-royalty, excess earnings and discounted cash flow.

Best for: Established brands, patents and products that already earn income

04

Option-based

What is the opportunity worth?

For early-stage patents, technology and R&D, we value the right, but not the obligation, to develop and commercialise the IP later, taking uncertainty into account.

Best for: Early-stage patents, technology and development projects

Frequently asked questions

It depends on the IP and why it is being valued. Established brands and earning patents usually suit income-based methods such as relief-from-royalty; newer assets suit cost-based methods; IP with an active market suits market-based comparisons; and early-stage technology suits option-based methods. We often combine methods and explain how we reconciled them.

Ready to move forward?

Tell us about your contract, dispute, business or project. We’ll get back to you to discuss the best way forward, with a clear quote before any work starts.

Talk to us